Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Poems (1sst post for the year)

Messy Room by Shel Silverstein
 Whosever room this is should be ashamed!
His underwear is hanging on the lamp.
His raincoat is there in the overstuffed chair,
And the chair is becoming quite mucky and damp.
His workbook is wedged in the window,
His sweater's been thrown on the floor.
His scarf and one ski are beneath the TV,
And his pants have been carelessly hung on the door.
His books are all jammed in the closet,
His vest has been left in the hall.
A lizard named Ed is asleep in his bed,
And his smelly old sock has been stuck to the wall.
Whosever room this is should be ashamed!
Donald or Robert or Willie or--
Huh? You say it's mine? Oh, dear,
I knew it looked familiar!

This poem has left a deep impression on me as, well, it describes my room perfectly! It probably describes every other singaporean student's room during exam time, too! However, there are different reasons. This poem is just sooo different from the what you'd expect. When you say poem, what comes to mind in most students is some dreary fifteen hundreds epic thats completely incomprehensible. Shel Silverstien's poems are not just non-deary and ancient with all that old english and "thy" and "thee" and "ye", its interesting, funny, and relevant to most people. What I think we can take away from this poem is that, they don't have to be long epics with very deep meanings that only boffins and Harvard grads can understand, they can be simple, funny, and be about as many things as there are brain cells in my head.

5 comments:

  1. This poem goes much deeper than describing a messy room. As with other books and poems written by Shel Silverstein, the author tries to and miraculously manages to make use of an everyday scene or a simple fictional story with a easy-to-follow plot to teach us a lesson in life.

    Going back to this poem, I can find at least two lessons that we can learn from this poem.

    Firstly, the author is trying to convey the message that in some points in our life, things can go uncontrollably many and hectic to the point that one cannot recognise one's life and the purpose of doing these things. However, one can tidy and clean up his room like one can organise his life to restore one's life to its original and proper pace.

    Secondly, the persona in the poem criticises the room for how messy it is but he never realises it is his room until someone tells him. This is a reminder to all of us that while we may criticise others, it is also important to keep ourselves in check, instead of "the pot calling the kettle black."

    Nevertheless, like what you have mentioned, these types of poems "don't have to be long epics with very deep meanings", and can be simple ones that allow us to relate to them and also act as a source of entertainment at the same time.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Kai Xuan,

    I agree with you on your statement that good poems "don't have to be long epics with very deep meanings that only boffins and Harvard grads can understand".

    It is an extremely difficult task to make a poem humorous and yet, at the same time, convey a message at the same time. However, in this poem, Shel Silverstein was able to have the best of both worlds - humour and morals.

    Despite the humour, though, Silverstein was able to skilfully express an ordinary phenomenon which I believe everyone faces. In layman terms, criticising others for mistakes we ourselves commit too, and as Ivan says it, "the pot calling the kettle black".

    On the whole, I enjoyed reading this poem, which goes beyond the superficial, literal depiction of a room, but instead expresses the inner, deeper meaning of human nature.

    Best Regards,
    Nathan :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kai Xuan,

    After reading your description and feelings towards the poem, I have a few comments to make.

    You have managed to prove the point that not all poems are "don't have to be long epics with very deep meanings that only boffins and Harvard grads can understand, they can be simple and funny". Shel Silverstein is known for his humorous and yet meaningful poems.

    However, your analysis of a poem is way too skimpy. This poem wasn't written just to describe how messy a room is, it also has an underlying meaning that must be inferred that it wants to tell its readers. This poem is trying to tell it's reader that at times our life will become hectic and messy. Also, the persona in the poem is criticizing someone but he does not realise that it is his own room till the end.

    Overall, I really enjoyed this poem as I find it humorous, and yet being able to express the true human nature at the same time.

    Keven

    ReplyDelete
  5. Actually, this poem is written as a children's poem. In the past, I did an analysis of this poem too, and I took the poem off a children's poem website.

    I agree with you that it can be meaningful and yet simple and humorous at the same time. However, I do not think that this poem has many different meanings. Actually, the ways of interpretation are actually very limited, seeing that it is a children's poem., targeted at children.

    I feel that the message of this poem is actually quite simple and easy to understand. I believe it is actually trying to convey the message that everyone should have a neater room than that in the poem. This is shown in the first line where "Whosever room this is should be ashamed". This shows the criticism of the messy room, and that the owners should be ashamed, hence discouraging the children readers to have messy rooms.

    Goh Xian Fong 2I1

    ReplyDelete